By Jay Fitzgerald – A blog about Boston, Hub of the Universe, and everything else.


Can Dems win the race to the populist center? Probably not

Bates College professor Tyler A. Harper is the latest to take whack at what’s ailing Dems these days – and it’s a pretty interesting look at the race between Republicans and Democrats to capture the “populist, post-neoliberal” center in America, a voting bloc roughly described thusly: “Americans who are moderate or even small-c conservative on social issues, but who also favor a more aggressive, rabble-rousing attack on the country’s existing economic system.” … As Harper notes in his Atlantic piece, Connecticut Sen. Chris Murphy has emerged as one of the leading advocates of Dems more aggressively courting working-class and other centrist voters. … The economic-focused approach is a sound one. But the problem is that the Democratic Party has a deeply entrenched, highly vocal and influential faction of college-educated progressives who value social issues far more than bread-and-butter economic issues – and they’ve woven those social-issues into a moralistic world view in which contrary opinions and compromise are seen as heresies. Look what happened to Seth Moulton when he dared to question just one orthodoxy, re trans-athletes. Defenders of the faith have all but vowed to run him out of the party. … What will it take to change things? It’s not going to happen by consensus. That’s a given. It’s probably going to take a Bill Clinton-type of centrist (without Clinton’s obvious personal liabilities) to shove and pull the party in a new direction. Even with a strong left-center leader, Dems aren’t going to suddenly shed most of their controversial social-issue stands. They may move toward the center. But they likely won’t capture and hold the center anytime soon. …

… Speaking of the future of the Democratic Party, Contrarian Boston’s Scott Van Voorhis hosted a chat the other day on what ails Dems. There’s a lot of moderate-Dem frustration out there, judging by CB subscribers’ comments. … And here’s more Dem doom-and-gloom pieces. From the Times: “Democrats Don’t Have an Easy Way Out.” … Also via the NYT: “Bad News, Democrats: America Is About to Get Even Redder.” … From Liberal Patriot: “How Democrats Misread the Environment.” … And from the Hill: “Democrats need change — Rahm Emanuel should lead the effort.”

Published by