
John Judis and Paul Krugman have dueling posts that try to answer the seemingly simple question: What is modern ‘democratic socialism’ in America? The two left-of-center pundits basically agree it’s not the ‘socialism’ of old, i.e. a movement favoring government control of the means of production. Instead, today’s democratic socialism is more akin to the European social democracy movement that advocates living with heavily regulated capitalism while providing generous social and safety-net programs to citizens, as Judis and Krugman argue. … So where do the two disagree? On how young people view today’s ‘democratic socialism’ and why they’ve embraced it. On this point alone, I tend to agree more with Judis, who argues it’s mostly about young voters’ limited post-Cold War perspective of history, politics and an economy that isn’t working so well for them. I’ll let Judis explain.
But here’s my problem with both of their analyses, setting aside my strong objections to many of the far left’s pie-in-the-sky economic policies: Where’s the detailed discussion of radical identity politics, Critical Race Theory and woke-ism that course through modern democratic socialism and the progressive left in general? Modern democratic socialism isn’t exclusively about economics and ‘affordability’ issues. It’s also about hot-button social issues – and far out social views that often directly contradict the left’s stated economic goals and turn off the vast majority of working-class voters and other Americans. It’s also about radical views on foreign policy and Israel in particular. Are young people embracing these clearly stated radical views when they embrace democratic socialism? John Judis, who now considers himself a democratic socialist, does address some of these thorny matters in a NYT interview and admits they’re a huge problem for the left. … Btw: If Judis is a democratic socialist, then he’s a moderate democratic socialist, one who used to regularly write for the common-sense Liberal Patriot that opposed Dems’ drift to the far left.



